The Art of Corruption: da Vinci and The U of Illinois Hospital
Over at the University of Illinois Hospital and Health Sciences System, they’re all waiting for the Ides of March.
That’s because, according to Charles Ornstein at Pro Publica, “The president of the University of Illinois system asked his vice president for research to investigate the matter and report back to him by March 15” to see if certain policies had been violated.
Of course, “The Matter” has already been investigated and all the president of the U of I has to do is read some blog posts by Paul Levy, who, Ornstein writes, runs a blog called Not Running a Hospital, and “began writing a series of posts about the ad. The first, called Time to Fire Somebody, ran on Jan. 22. ‘The University has allowed its reputation to be used in a nationally distributed advertisement produced and owned by a private party, in benefit to that party’s commercial objectives. This is not consistent with ‘exercising custodial responsibility for University property and resources,’’ it said.
The ad is for for a robotic surgical system called “da Vinci,” which, depending on whether you listen to patient safety advocates or sales reps and the doctors on their pad, is either a dangerous and expensive piece of crap or a state of the art high-tech instrument used to perform “minimally invasive” surgical procedures.
The matter is that the ad, which ran in the New York Times Sunday magazine recently, “prominently featured a dozen members of the surgery team at the University of Illinois Hospital and Health Sciences System,” was bought and paid for by the da Vinci company — as were, apparently, the Docs.
This courtesy Trish Torrey, About.com Patient Empowerment: Don’t “fall” for the idea of the use of the robot. Studies show it probably doesn’t improve anything for you over that minimally invasive approach. (See reports from the Wall Street Journal, NPR and USA Today.)